George C. Carens Award (For contribution to New England football)
| Year | Name | Association |
| 1952 | Paul Swaffield | EIFO |
| 1953 | John Pappas, Sr. | Boston University |
| 1954 | Alva Kelley | Brown |
| 1955 | Tuss McLaughry | Dartmouth |
| 1956 | Clarence Houston | Tufts |
| 1957 | Bill Cunningham | Boston Herald |
| 1958 | Rev. Joseph Maxwell | Boston College |
| 1959 | Jack Fadden | Harvard |
| 1960 | Dr. Eddie Anderson | Holy Cross |
| 1961 | Len Waters | Williams |
| 1962 | Swede Nelson | Gridiron Club |
| 1963 | Arthur Sampson | Boston Herald |
| 1964 | Joe McKenney | Boston College |
| 1965 | Harry Arlanson | Tufts |
| 1966 | Dan Jessee | Trinity |
| 1967 | Murray Lewis | Tobacco Table |
| 1968 | Murray Kraemer | Boston Record |
| 1969 | Leroy Kelley | EIFO |
| 1970 | John P. Curley | Boston College |
| 1971 | Warren McGuirk | Massachusetts |
| 1972 | Roy Mumpton | Worcester Telegram |
| 1973 | Jerry Nason | Boston Globe |
| 1974 | Joe Zabilski | Northeastern |
| 1975 | Jack Daly | EIFO |
| 1976 | Tim Cohane | Fordham |
| 1977 | Tedd Dunn | Springfield |
| 1978 | Dave Morey | Dartmouth |
| 1979 | Dick Page | Massachusetts |
| 1980 | Gus Sullivan | Boston State |
| 1981 | Foxy Flumere | Northeastern/Brandeis |
| 1982 | John Baronian | Tufts |
| 1983 | Ernie Roberts | Boston Globe |
| 1984 | Harry Jacunski | Yale |
| 1985 | Ken Hudson | Coca-Cola |
| 1986 | Joe Yukica | UNH/Dartmouth/Boston College |
| 1987 | Bob Odell | Williams |
| 1988 | Scotty Whitelaw | ECAC |
| 1989 | Harold Koop | Rhode Island |
| 1990 | Bill Flynn | Boston College |
| 1991 | Dave O'Hara | Associated Press |
| 1992 | Jim Ostendarp | Amherst |
| 1993 | Joe Restic | Harvard |
| 1994 | Mike Linkovich | Bowdoin |
| 1995 | Carmen Cozza | Yale |
| 1996 | Pete Mazzaferro | Bridgewater |
| 1997 | Al Benson | ECAC |
| 1998 | Rocky Carzo | Tufts |
| 1999 | Joe Concannon | Boston Globe |
| 2000 | Don Miller | Trinity |
| 2001 | Bob Monahan | Boston Globe |
| 2002 | Bill Bowes | New Hampshire |
| 2003 | Howard Vandersea | Bowdoin |
| 2004 | John Bicknell | Maine/Boston College |
| 2005 | William Mottola | ME Maritime |
| 2006 | Dick Farley | Williams |
| 2007 | George Hale | Maine |
| 2008 | Bob Pickett | Massachusetts |
| 2009 | Peter Yetten | Bentley |
Return to newenglandallstars.com | Web site presented by Pack Network